Universitat Pompeu Fabra
Library & IT Services

6. Evaluate the resources you found

How to prepare
your academic paper
Start
Steps to prepare your academic paper Find Internet resources Evaluate the resources found Situate the subject within its context Find articles from journals Find books, journals, audiovisuals, etc. Formulate the subject of your academic paper Write up your academic paper Cite your chosen resources Find Internet resources Evaluate the resources found Situate the subject within its context Find articles from journals Find books, journals, audiovisuals, etc.

Do a critical analysis of the sources located in order to pick up the good quality academic information. Below you will find a list of questions for checking the reliability of the material located.


Questions Take note of
Who?

Fletxeta Who is the author?

Fletxeta Is he/she an expert in his/her field?
Fletxeta Of which institution is he/she a member?
What?
Fletxeta What is it about?
Fletxeta The information is complete and accurate
Fletxeta It shows the sources of information and/or the source of the data
Fletxeta The conclusions seem justified
When?
Fletxeta Is the information up-to-date?
Fletxeta What is the date of the article/book?
Fletxeta When was the website last updated?
Fletxeta Is it necessary to obtain more information in order to update the data?
Where?
Fletxeta Where is the information located?
Fletxeta Where does the information come from?
Fletxeta The website is on a personal, institutional or commercial server
Fletxeta The reputation of the book or journal publishers
Why?
Fletxeta To whom is the page addressed?
Fletxeta A specific target public (experts, children, etc.)
Fletxeta It is trying to recommend or sell a product
Fletxeta It tries to influence one's opinion




Other web resources according to the type of material:

Type of resources Consult
Any /All

Fletxeta Consult the guide ¿Cómo evaluar fuentes de información? [How to evaluate sources of information] (Universidad de Málaga. Biblioteca) 
Fletxeta Consult the resource Critical Evaluation of Resources (University of California, Berkeley)


Books

Fletxeta Search for book critics, comments or accounts
Fletxeta Check: editor, organization and content, date of publication, author, target public and graphics. You can consult How to evaluate books (Colorado State University Libraries)


Journals

Fletxeta You can consult Criterios para escoger la revista [Criteria for choosing the journal] (from the Manual de redacción científica by José A. Mari, Universidad de Puerto Rico)


Websites

Fletxeta Look for information about the website: author, updates, purpose, etc.
Fletxeta You can consult Evaluating information on the web (Iowa State University. E-Library)

 

Steps to prepare your academic paper Find Internet resources Evaluate the resources found Situate the subject within its context Find articles from journals Find books, journals, audiovisuals, etc. Formulate the subject of your academic paper Write up your academic paper Cite your chosen resources Find Internet resources Evaluate the resources found Situate the subject within its context Find articles from journals Find books, journals, audiovisuals, etc. Formulate the subject of your academic paper Write up your academic paper Cite your chosen resources

Last updated 30-10-2008
© Universitat Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona